Talk About Network

Google





Education > Math Recreational > Re: Trisection ...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 2 of 5 Topic 2738 of 2947
Post > Topic >>

Re: Trisection Solution

by Laurence Reeves <l@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Apr 7, 2008 at 11:21 AM

Jon G. wrote:
> Suppose you have 3 timbers of odd lengths, and plant them on the ground
to 
> form a pyramid.  If you know the lengths of the 3 timbers, and where you

> plant them on the ground, this Excel worksheet will find the apex of the

> pyramid where the 3 timbers meet.  You only need use Sheet 1 for instant

> answers.
> 
> http://www.freefileserver.com/index/p_download/hash_Ihywe3KYeyzT/
> 
> The math behind this is in my web site,
> 
> http://mypeoplepc.com/members/jon8338/math/index.html
> 
I fail to see quite why you would want to approach this problem in such 
a complex way. Given your static A, B and C point, with the distances to 
your unknown point D, it is fairly trivial 3D geometry to locate D (if 
there exists a solution).

E.g. you could note that D lies on the circular locus implied by its 
distances from A and B, plus it also lies on the appropriate sphere 
about C. The circle may intersect the sphere in two points, reflections 
in ABC (or coincident in that plane). A somewhat "lop-sided" route, but 
it works.

I think that the conditions for a solution to exist are simply that each 
of the three triangles formed above ABC must be possible individually. 
          However, I'm not certain about that being necessary (nine 
inequalities sounds too many) and sufficient (although maybe it is).

-- 
Lau AS! d-(!) a++ c++++ p++ t+ f-- e++ h+ r--(+) n++(*) i++ P- m++
ASC Decoder at <http://www32.brinkster.com/ascdecode/>
 




 5 Posts in Topic:
Trisection Solution
"Jon G." <jo  2008-04-06 20:40:11 
Re: Trisection Solution
Laurence Reeves <l@[EM  2008-04-07 11:21:37 
Re: Trisection Solution
hagman <google@[EMAIL   2008-04-07 04:24:23 
Re: Trisection Solution
Laurence Reeves <l@[EM  2008-04-07 22:47:06 
Re: Trisection Solution
"Jon G." <jo  2008-04-08 08:26:49 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
localhost-V2008-12-19 Thu Jan 8 12:15:40 PST 2009.